Classics Book Reviews: Don Quijote (Norton Critical Editions)

 
Reviews of Don Quijote (Norton Critical Editions)

    - Publication information
    - Buy this book

Review #1: What books become classics? The great ones!
Review #2: Tobia Smollet's translation is still the best
Review #3: Brilliant Translation





Review #1

What books become classics? The great ones!

Hardly a day goes by without a reference to tilting at windmills or other quixotic behavior in the media or conversation. Few people under the age of 60 have actually read Don Quixote! Its a wonderful book; both a great read and food for thought. This translation is fresh, while keeping the feel of Cervantes' era. The notes and intro are essential to unlocking the background for modern readers.




Review #2

Tobia Smollet's translation is still the best

Smollet's trnslation is the most pungent of them all. It is highly readable and was recommended to me by DOn Quixote scholar Roberto Echeverria (Yale Univ)Don Quixote (Barnes & Noble Classics). I find the 2003 Grossman translation unreadable.




Review #3

Brilliant Translation

Raffel's translation of Cervante's masterpiece is remarkably good. I hadn't read Don Quijote in a number of years and about a week ago I tried to read the Ormsby translation. About one hundred pages in, I stopped reading it and ordered the Norton edition with Raffel's translation. Raffel's translation brings the text to life and captures the humor and personality of the book in such a natural way that it makes the other translations somewhat painful to read.




Check for more reviews on Amazon.com


Similar Products:



Don Quijote (Norton Critical Editions)

by Miguel De Cervantes

Format: Paperback
Publication Date: 1999-01-17
Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company
ISBN: 039397281X

    List Price:
Price: $12.04
Usually ships in 24 hours

Buy from Amazon.com
Buy from Amazon.ca
Buy from Amazon.co.uk

Don Quijote (Norton Critical Editions) Reviews


book-reviews.info home


Book-Reviews.info





Search for more book reviews:




Browse for Book Reviews:



Page last updated on: 6 Sep 2010