Kosher Cookbook Reviews: The New York Times Passover Cookbook

 
Reviews of The New York Times Passover Cookbook : More Than 200 Holiday Recipes from Top Chefs and Writers

    - Publication information
    - Buy this book

Review #1: Best passover cookbook ever
Review #2: Very good
Review #3: Great for foodies, not for someone who's spent hours cleaning for Pesach





Review #1

Best passover cookbook ever

The best kosher passover cookbook I've ever seen. The recipes are very good, and the variety is top notch. Truthfully I find a lot of cookbooks a little boring, but this is a Julia Child, Claudia Roden quality cookbook.




Review #2

Very good

I really liked the book. My friends raved about the Sweet and Sour Beets recipe. My only suggestion for improvement would be to give specific instructions for the Sedar plate and suggest different menus for a Sedar.




Review #3

Great for foodies, not for someone who's spent hours cleaning for Pesach

I wish I had read the negative review about this cookbook and given a little more thought to the target audience of this book. I was online and bought a handful of different Passover recipe books, without agonizing too much over which one I should get. I was certainly not in the target audience.

The up-side is that it has SOOOOO many recipes and from many different (famed and trendy) contributors. If you are a foodie, are serving foodies, or really care about impressing your guests with the dinner, then this is a great resource.

But if you've just spent 2 weeks cleaning every niche and crevice of your home and kashering your kitchen and sleeping for about 3 hours a night (or maybe you're just a busy person and don't have the time), you might not want a cookbook that is filled with recipes that require about 10-20 ingredients -- especially when each ingredient may only affect the flavor subtly. Not everyone who is coming for Pesach dinner is going to have the palette to appreciate my killing myself over the meal -- especially when the invitees may very well include Uncle Max who just prefers gefilte fish out of a jar and bratty or picky kids who just want matzo ball soup and would cry if you try to do anything fancy or different to the matzo balls.

Moreover, as another reviewer wrote, the kashrus standards of the recipes are not necessarily according to Orthodox levels. There are recipes in the book for making matza yourself, which isn't really recommended, especially since the whole point of Passover is to avoid leavening and you won't necessarily do that unless you bake the matzohs fast enough. But those were the only recipes that I found had flour in it. The book is pretty good otherwise about keeping things kosher.

I happen to also love cookbooks with lots of color photos. This is not one of them. But to each his own. It does have a lovely section in the middle with a handful of photos of selected recipes.

For like-minded people, I would recommend taking a look at Susie Fishbein's Passover cookbook (although those of you who have her Kosher by Design series may find some of the recipes repetitive) and Susan Friedland's Passover Table book.




Check for more reviews on Amazon.com


Similar Products:



The New York Times Passover Cookbook : More Than 200 Holiday Recipes from Top Chefs and Writers

by Linda Amster

Format: Hardcover
Publication Date: 1999-03-03
Publisher: William Morrow Cookbooks
ISBN: 0688155901

    List Price: $25.00
Price: $13.51
Usually ships in 24 hours

Buy from Amazon.com
Buy from Amazon.ca
Buy from Amazon.co.uk

The New York Times Passover Cookbook Reviews


book-reviews.info home


Book-Reviews.info





Search for more book reviews:




Browse for Book Reviews:



Page last updated on: 21 Mar 2010